Factory Automation
Batch Processing
Process Automation
Packaging Automation
On the Edge
Download this free 94-page Continuous Process Playbook loaded with industry expert advice on topics ranging from control systems, instrumentation, and industrial networks to energy management, security, and system upgrades.
Pinto's Prose

Automation Innovation Paradigms

Print Reprint

Radical innovation is disruptive. It creates an inflection point that generates fast growth for the innovators and inevitable decline for those that are stuck in old paradigms. In the automation business few companies originate radically new technology to generate growth; usually, commercial technology is adapted for industrial needs. The two largest segments of industrial measurement & control systems—Programmable Logic Controllers (PLC) and Distributed Control Systems (DCS)—were 1970’s era developments but give hints of the future.

The PLC was invented in response to the needs of U.S. automotive manufacturers. Control, sequencing, and safety interlock logic for automobile production was accomplished using large numbers of relays, cam timers, drum sequencers and dedicated closed-loop controllers. Because electricians needed to rewire hard-wired backplanes, the process for updating facilities for the yearly model changeover was time consuming and expensive. PLC relay ladder logic allowed quick re-programming by the average electrician. Some four decades later, the PLC has become a commodity and the market is worth several billions of dollars.

DCS reduced the complexity of large central control rooms with mainframe computers by offering much smaller size at a drastically reduced price. DCS has now morphed into different shapes, sizes and form-factors; this market segment too has expanded to several billions of dollars worldwide.

While there are isolated pockets of growth in the automation business, no other innovations have succeeded in achieving an equivalent inflection point by offering improvements of ten times or more in price, performance and operating advantages.

The only recent innovation that was developed to address true customer needs is Emerson Process Management’s CHARMS. Recognizing that input/output (I/O) connections represent the bulk of wiring in the typical process control system, this innovative rethink of I/O wiring, called “I/O on Demand,” essentially eliminates the need for a physical path from signal-source to controller. Instead, new single-channel CHARacterization ModuleS (CHARMS - cute name) relay I/O info via the Ethernet backbone to any controller, providing single channel integrity and flexibility down to the channel level. On a typical project with thousands of hardwired points, I/O-on-demand can eliminate as much as 90 percent of intra-cabinet wiring—the magical 10-times improvement which signals an inflection point in the market.

The next innovation
Where might the next automation innovation paradigm shift occur? For one, wireless is a broad-based enabling technology, but most automation majors have failed to pursue the true breadth and depth of the shift in capabilities. They offer the same form-factor, complexity, sales channels and pricing margins to maintain the same-old, same-old financial ratios. No one has reduced size, price and complexity to a level that stimulates use in a much wider range of applications across broader markets. Soon there will be a plethora of inexpensive WiFi-based sensors all over process plants and factories. Perhaps this can only be done by an upstart, entrepreneurial enterprise or new entries from China or India.

iPad and its equivalents may deliver another automation paradigm shift. One has only to view the dinosaur that blinks on the cover of WIRED magazine, or read the latest issue of Time with touch-text and multi-media advertising, or browse the latest iPad issue of Automation World, to recognize the imminent demise of snail-mail print delivery which arrives days later. Or, what about iPad versions of operator interface? Review the advantages of the latest iPad version of ThinManager 6.0 for example.


Automation is overdue for the emergence of new innovation paradigms. Look for new leaders to blaze the path to explosive new growth.

Read what ten technology trends will affect the Automation Team in 2012. Visit

>> Jim Pinto is a technology futurist, international speaker and automation industry commentator. You can email him at [email protected] or review his prognostications and predictions on his website:



Well, of course I have a blatant bias, but I think what we're doing at ThingWorx is indicative of what the next generation of applications in the manufacturing and industrial space will look like. Collaborative, mashable, connected with other "networks" (energy, transporation, human, vendor), valuing people and their knowledge, mobile, and ubiquitous. There is a lot that we've collectively learned in the automation industry that has applicability in the broader world of connected "things" and related applications. There is also a lot of technology in the enterprise and consumer spaces that can and need to be applied in the industrial domains. We've taking a lot of these concepts along with a whole lot of new technology and put it together as the ThingWorx platform. Time will tell whether the world is ready for it, but initial indications are very promising!

Jim - I enjoy reading your articles and absolutely agree that "automation is overdue for the emergence of new innovation paradigms." Obviously the timeline on the next "new innovation" is elusive and agreeable with stagnant and/or outdated "innovation paradigms." It seems companies are content modifying existing technologies and creating redundant ones, as well (typically less expensive and lower quality products). This isn't bad; it stimulates creativity but tends to snuff out innovation. Perhaps it's economic in nature - I don't know. But, innovation must be encouraged at all levels (i.e., home, school, work, etc.) and opportunities afforded at every socioeconomic level. While innovation has no respect for socioeconomic boundaries, I wonder if many "innovation paradigms" are adhered to due to economic reasons (e.g., funding).

Add new comment


Don't miss intelligence crucial to your job and business!
Click on any newsletter to view a sample. Enter your email address below to sign up!
Each newsletter ranges in frequency from once per month to a few times per month at most.
IT Delivers on Automation’s Promise
E-Book Special Report
IT Delivers on Automation’s Promise

Sign up to receive timely updates from the editors at Automation World and download this FREE Special Report on the transformative power of data in manufacturing. By integrating information and automation technologies, manufacturers are finally achieving major gains in productivity from their automated systems.