Nested Niches

Industrial automation seems like a large, unified market, but it’s not; rather, it’s a loose conglomeration of diverse market segments and specialized applications.

Aw 565 Jimpinto Web
Industrial markets that automation companies serve include manufacturing (everything from automobiles to appliances, tennis-balls to toasters); petrochemical (production and pipelines); pharmaceuticals; electric and nuclear power; water and waste; food and beverage; paper and pulp; metals; mining—a long list of fragmented markets, each with special requirements, regulations, pricing and services. Smaller companies target narrow niches and geography, while larger suppliers serve broader markets with variations of standard products. Most automation majors have target-market teams as part of their overall marketing/sales focus.

Automation products are all kinds of specialized gadgets and instruments—sensors, displays, recorders and actuators—and a wide variety of systems with a mixture of those products, plus software and services. There are very few requirements for high quantities of any particular product—hardly any millions of anything. Millions of products are used, but many are specialized variations related to particular industries and requirements.

There are two major product segments for systems:

• Distributed Control Systems (DCS): Relatively large computer systems supplied by just a handful of major companies. More than 50 percent of revenue is related to services.

• Programmable logic controllers (PLCs): Relatively small, input/output (I/O)- focused control products, now morphed into a variety of shapes and sizes, becoming almost commodities.

Historically, PLC applications remained focused around discrete automation markets, while DCS expanded primarily in larger process control systems. Then discrete control migrated into remote input/output (I/O) clusters and industrial networks. Soon, personal computers (PCs) became the easiest way to connect DCS, PLCs and remote I/O into the rapidly expanding hierarchy of factory and process networks and eventually, the Internet.

In this mix, the markets for industrial PC software expanded, initially as human-machine interface (HMI), with expansions for displays, data logging, historical analysis and the like. Although used across a broad array of market segments, the total available market for independent packaged software was limited. The large process controls suppliers acquired the leaders and expanded into related software arenas—manufacturing execution systems (MES) and the like.

Beyond these middle products are the field devices—sensors (for measuring process variables such as temperature, pressure, flow, speed, position, load and pH) and actuators at the other end of the system (heaters, valves, motors, solenoids, positioners and so on) to control those same variables. Each of these has special requirements in different markets, relating to physical size, shape, operating temperatures and physical environment. Again, specialized niche companies cater to specific applications and requirements, while the majors supply a broader base over wider geographical territories.

Diverse and confusing

All these different products are sold to these fragmented markets with sales and distribution channels that are equally diverse and confusing. Small companies have independent sales representatives and distributors who focus on exclusive geographic territories with several lines of complementary products. Larger companies tend to have more representatives and stocking distributors. Most automation majors try to integrate all of the above channels with their own sales people focusing on primary customers.

Because automation is such a fragmented business, mid-sized "mini-conglomerates," such as Ametek, Roper Industries, Spectris and others, grow primarily through acquisition of small, innovative, niche product companies (typically $10 million to $20 million annual revenue) whose growth has been self-limited through lack of capital for new products and/or global sales expansion. The automation majors—just a handful of multi-billion-dollar companies—are all combinations of medium-sized and small divisions. They are just like matryoshkas or Russian dolls, each nested within a larger group, down to niche-related $10 million to $20 million and even smaller pieces—reflecting the market as a whole.

Jim Pinto is an industry analyst and commentator, writer, technology futurist and angel investor. You can e-mail him at: jim@jimpinto.com. Or review his prognostications and predictions on his Web site: www.jimpinto.com.

Subscribe to Automation World's RSS Feeds for Columns & Departments

More in Control