Automation World’s article, “Engineers Split on Motor Oversizing," contained information from a reader survey on the pros and cons of oversizing motors. Read more reader feedback.
Though Automation World received a lot of positive feedback about what was included in that article, a reader named Buck commented on what we did not include:
“I did not see any commenting on the increased power loss due to poor power factor caused by a partially loaded motor. I would also have expected something about using a motor suitable for VFDs. The new VFDs have harmonics that can cause heat, AND eddy currents induced in these motors can cause bearing failures. There was no mention of using protective devices in the motor to discharge these currents.
“If you increase the motor size, you will add the cost of the motor, starter or VFD, fusing or safety devices, wiring, local disconnect for LOTO [lock out, tag out], and inrush to start the motor. I would suggest that if you are not sure of the size of the motor needed and you oversize, you should wasted energy. But you will have the effects of the VFD on the motor windings and bearings.”
We’re happy to keep the conversation going. View the original article at http://awgo.to/293, or visit our Facebook orLinkedIn pages to join the discussions.
From robotic arms to high-speed conveyors, accuracy matters. Discover how encoders transform motor control by turning motion into real-time data?delivering tighter speed control...
Inductive Automation offers multiple editions of Ignition created for specific use cases. See what differentiates Ignition, Ignition Edge, Ignition Cloud Edition, and Ignition...
Castle & Key brought new life to a historic Kentucky distillery by blending 140 years of heritage with cutting-edge automation. With help from Gray AES, they replaced outdated...
